Hayden Rejection - One Small Step
Party in question: Amy Hayden of Linn Prentis Literary
Query sent: February 5, 2013
Answer received: March 28, 2013
Read as follows:
Trodayne here hijacking Amy's email. She wanted me to read your sample.
Your writing has a lot going for it and your query was quite strong. As
I read your synopsis and query I found myself intrigued. But as I
finished your sample I was left hesitating on requesting more. The plot
seems to work well enough. From what I can tell the characters work as
well. I know you can write a strong action scene. That much you clearly
demonstrated quite effectively in the prologue. But then you
demonstrated it again and again in the pages following it. As much as I
did like the premise and the first part of your sample, I found myself
feeling a sense of repetition as I continued to read. I believe the
contours of the writing didn't progress as much as I'd hoped. I must
trust my instincts in this case and pass but Linn Prentis Literary
would welcome, no, we would encourage future submissions from you,
Jaimie.
Trodayne Northern
Acquisition Director
I think this is perhaps as good as a rejection gets, at least in my world! Though disappointment was inevitable, I am (obviously) quite motivated to send my next project Mr. Northern's way.
I was fairly kicking myself after reading this particular email. The beginning of my novel - sans the prologue, as I wrote that after I finished the first draft - is probably the weakest part of the book. I knew that, and many beta readers told me so in so many words, but I didn't want to scrap the whole thing and rewrite it. Now I wonder what my fate would've been had made the extra effort to do so.
But, as they say, what's past is past. I am certainly aware of my tendency toward slow beginnings, as that is one of the critiques I've received about my ongoing "Bloodlines of Epheria" serial. The next time around, I will pay special attention to wholly grabbing the reader's attention from the get-go.
And so, The Great Agent Hunt continues...